From the WIP

« Not Your Typical Nobel Laureate: Amartya Sen on Distorted Multiculturalism | Main | Democracy Takes a Hit on the Campaign Trail »

January 19, 2008

Turn Back South: Immigration Through the Lens of a Bosnian Immigrant

Jessica Mosby

by Jessica Mosby
- USA -


Though the United States is a country of immigrants, immigration divides the culture and fuels an endless debate clouded by strong emotion on both sides. Over 11.3 million people are living illegally in the US and three-fourths of these illegal immigrants come from Latin America, having crossed the Mexican border to enter the country. The Department of Homeland Security wants to build a wall along America’s border with Mexico to stem this flow, a move equally hailed and derided—depending on the perspective of the commentators. The federal government has also increased efforts to arrest and deport illegal immigrants, often under the guise of anti-terrorism efforts. But on the other hand, some states are proposing giving illegal immigrants driver’s licenses, and, while official policies forbid employing them, illegal immigrants can easily find jobs in agriculture and construction. Even with unlawfully low wages and exploitation, they will make more money than they could in their home country. There are no easy answers to this incredibly complex problem.


Each year, thousands of illegal immigrants cross US borders, risking their lives in often treacherous conditions. Photograph courtesy of the filmmaker.
Igor Borovac’s documentary short, Turn Back South injects some perspective and humanity into the immigration reform debate. Borovac attempts to assess the situation at the Mexican-American border through an objective lens; he allows both the potential immigrants and the border patrol agents tasked to stop them to talk freely about their perspectives. The 11 minute short documents the situation at the Mexican-American border with impressive footage, including some determined people trying to float into the US via a river of sewage and trash and their tense standoff with border patrol agents. At one point the agents, frustrated and unwilling to enter the dangerously polluted water, threaten to shoot the offenders. The film captures the sadness and loss that people experience when attempting to cross the border—if they survive. The urgent need for reform informs this raw footage, but subtly.

Borovac’s background as a Bosnian immigrant by way of Germany makes the film especially intriguing. He and his family left their home in Bosnia in 1994 because, “There was no hope that the long-raging war would end any time soon.” After living in Germany for six years, he left his family and immigrated to the U.S. as part of a refugee program. The program required him to live near his sponsor, who lived in Monterey, California. With a love of photography and journalism, he decided to attend California State University Monterey Bay’s Teledramatic Arts and Technology program.

In my interview with him, Borovac discusses why he made the film, the process of making a low-budget independent documentary, and what he hopes viewers will take away from the film’s raw footage.


Why did you decide to make a documentary film about immigrants at the Mexican-American border?

A great friend of mine and remarkable photographer Nico Mavris was already involved in using still photography to expose what was happening in the border lands. On my first trip with Nico, I used two photo cameras, but I felt that I could tell a better story if I captured it on video. Soon enough we were down at the California and Arizona borders with Mexico with full gear and no script, filming and interviewing everything and everyone we thought would help us understand what was going on. It came as a shock to me that things that I saw were happening so close to where we live peacefully.

How did your own immigrant experience influence your decision to make Turn Back South?

My own experience did not play an active role in my decision; however, some of the situations we filmed felt familiar to me. My life experience had more of an effect after I had already decided to make the film. It helped me find the humanity in the situations. I felt like I understood the people involved.


After wading through sewage and polluted waters, these immigrants are met by border agents. Photograph courtesy of the filmmaker.
When did you become interested in documentary film?

I developed a love for photography quite early in my life and was always passionate about filmmaking. I studied photography for a while and rapidly became interested in the journalistic aspect of it. It was just a matter of time I realized that documentary filmmaking is really what I’m after.

How did you fund the production of Turn Back South?

Out of our own pockets, mostly mine. We also got a CSUMB Capstone (graduation) Grant which helped us with postproduction of the film.

Did the film program at CSUMB help?

Definitely. CSUMB has amazing equipment and great facilities for postproduction. I can’t give enough thanks to the entire TAT faculty, especially Caitlin Manning and Dan Janos. And again, they gave us that grant which we totally needed and deserved.

When and where did you film Turn Back South?

We started filming in late 2003, but most of the footage was taken over three trips in 2004. In 2006, we went back to get a couple more interviews, just before I was going to graduate. The footage was gathered in many places, including Tijuana, Bisbee, and Nogales. However the most important sites were Calexico, Yuma and Mexicali.

What was the most challenging part of making an independent documentary film?

Financing. Initially it would seem like that would not be the biggest challenge. This type of documentary filmmaking isn’t easy. I like travel, challenge and the guerilla-style filming we did. The combination of these three will create some tense situations no matter which part of the world you’re in or which border you’re at. You have to keep cool and smart, deal with everything going on, and still walk away with what you need. Even with all these and a great idea, you still can’t do anything if you can’t pay for it.

To get financing, you not only have to deliver, you have to prove that you can deliver before you have anything to show, and that’s tough.

Was it difficult to find people who were willing to be interviewed while the cameras were rolling?

No, it was not. People like to tell stories. The problem is getting them to say what they really think.

I know the film has played at a number of film festivals, how has the film been received?


A border agent pulls a border crosser to the safety of the river bank. Photograph courtesy of the filmmaker.
We won third place in the documentary section of the CSU Media Arts Festival. Also, the film was very well received at the Mill Valley Film Festival where viewers’ questions at the end of the each screening demonstrated the public’s interest in the issues surrounding our borders. The film played at the Boston Film Festival, New York City Shorts, and the International Film Festival in San Francisco. We are waiting for a few more submission decisions.


What would you like people to take away from Turn Back South?

I hope that this film sheds some new light on immigration and the issues surrounding it. We tried not to talk about politics, but to address the humanity in the whole situation. To show that it’s not just a cultural problem, a political issue, or an abstract concept. Immigrants and border patrol agents are real people who are on the opposite sides of the border. They are human beings whose actions and lives are being ignored because of today’s politics.

What are your future film-making plans? Do you plan to continue to make documentary films about controversial and political issues?

Well, the next documentary that I am part of is about comic books. I am working as a camera assistant. The documentary focuses on Al Capp and his work, comic strips such as Lil’ Abner, Daisy May, etc. This is a completely different type of documentary from Turn Back South, with entirely different themes. I have already started my next personal project, and we have already shot some footage. It is about Punto Guajiro, an ancient type of singing from the western provinces of Cuba.



To view the Turn Back South trailer, click this link, scroll down and click on the Movies tab.



About the Author Jessica Mosby is a writer and critic living in Berkeley, California. In the rare moments when she's not traveling across the United States for work, Jessica enjoys listening to public radio, buying organic food at local farmers markets, trolling junk stores, and collecting owl-themed tchotchke.

Comments (4)

I am struck by this filmmaker's dedication to the humanity of those caught up in one of the most challenging problems in the world today. It is so easy for people to become entrenched in their position on any controversial issue, so immigration is no exception. This film appears to allow viewers to see everyone as human beings. Thank you, Jessica, and the WIP for a moving interview.

Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger is expected next month to gear-up immediately for major cuts in state services, which includes a plan to take back $1.4 billion budgeted for education this year and a proposal to slash the prison population by releasing tens of thousands of low- risk inmates.

The two strategies are among a wide spectrum of spending reductions The governor will propose an outline to address a projected $14.5-billion state budget gap. On Friday, the Republican announced that he would declare a fiscal emergency Jan. 10, when he unveils his next budget.

In hosting this nations largest population of illegal immigrants, California masses huge cost to provide basic human services for this fast growing, low-income, poorly educated segment of the state. A new study from the Federation for American Immigration Reform (FAIR) investigated the costs of education, health care and imprisonment of illegal aliens, and concludes that the costs to Californians is $10.5 billion per year. and rising. Among the key finding of the report are that California is already struggling K-12 education system. It spends approximately $7.7 billion a year to educate the children of illegal aliens who now constitute 15 percent of the student body. Another $1.4 billion of the taxpayers' money goes toward providing health care to illegal aliens and their families, the same amount that is spent incarcerating illegal aliens criminals. Taxpayers have to supplement thousands of rogue businesses who pay low wages and offer no healthcare or any other benefits. Hense taxpayers are forced by Federal and state law to support the California population of foreign nationals with their large families, who need subsidised shelter, healthcare and other government handouts they never paid into.

Taxpayers must realize their taxes are corporate welfare, because the contractor or company owner gets the profit from hiring illegal workers and walks away quite happily without any further obligations. When injured a illegal foreign national is more than likely to be dropped-off on the steps of a hospital emergency, where you the citizen pay the huge expense for surgery or any other longtime hospitalization?

"The Golden state's addiction to 'cheap' illegal slave labor is bankrupting the state coffers and posing enormous pressure on the state's shrinking middle class tax base," stated Dan Stein, President of FAIR. "Most Californians, who have seen their taxes increase while public services deteriorate, already know the impact that mass illegal immigration is having on their communities, but even they may be shocked when they learn just how much of a drain illegal immigration has become."

The annual cost to taxpayers is about $22 billion a year according to Center for Immigration Studies and the tax burden will grow -- because 15 million more immigrants are set to arrive by year 2017 according to their latest research.

More than 10 million immigrants have arrived since year 2000; it is estimated that nearly 6 million are illegal. All told, the group of immigrants now account for 38 million at the moment according to the White House's own census bureau.

Remember this when you vote on super Tuesday? It's your tax dollars officials are spending and allowing California to become a magnet to millions of free-loaders, while citizens suffering the consequences of a "Sanctuary State" mentality.

Remember when you vote on "Super Tuesday" that your vote portends the future of your children, your job, your language and the Constitution? This free-movement of illegal, cheap labor, is the underhand agenda of the globalist open-border, terrible free trade. This occurance has already taken hold in the European Union, which is causing untold misery in countries like Britain. Most Democrats have voted for AMNESTY, whereas only to Presidential candidates have signed a pledge to stop any path to citizenship for the estimated 12 to 20 million illegal immigrants.

For unsuppressed news go to NUMBERSUSA and you decide the future of California and our great nation.

I really enjoyed reading this article and would love to show the film at my school - The Monterey Institute of International Studies. Where can I find a copy of the film?
Thanks so much.

Hi Jeanette,

I hope that you have been able to connect with Mr. Borovac about screening Turn Back South at MIIS. Please be sure to let our local readers know if there will be a screening by leaving another comment. I'm sure there are many people who would love to attend.

Thanks!

Ad Space Holder

Leave a comment

BlogHer Ad Network
More from BlogHer
Advertise here
BlogHer Privacy Policy

RECENT ARTICLES

Arts & Culture
Economy
Education
Politics
Science
Special Election Coverage
Technology
The WIP Editorial
The World