From the WIP

« Modern Malaysia Grapples with Islamization | Main | More than Olives and Sunshine: Spain’s Carte de Salud »

September 11, 2009

The Water Front: Fighting to Keep the Tap On

Jessica Mosby

by Jessica Mosby
- USA -


Highland Park, Michigan would seem an unlikely candidate for water access problems – the city is located on the Great Lakes, the largest group of freshwater lakes in the world. The Great Lakes are so vast that when standing on their shores you cannot see the other side. With freshwater so ubiquitous, why did Highland Park’s mostly low-income and elderly residents have to fight to keep the water flowing from their taps? The new 53-minute documentary film, The Water Front, skillfully documents Highland Park’s long and heated fight over water access and cost.

mosby_bill.jpg
Faced with ridiculously priced water bills, many residents fled Highland Park. Photograph courtesy of the filmmakers.
The saga begins with the once booming bedroom community of Detroit falling into economic peril. At its height, the city was 60,000 residents strong with a tax base to match; as the American auto industry declined, manufacturing jobs disappeared and the population suffered. By 2000, entire streets are lined with abandoned houses, trash collects on desolate curbs and prosperity is nowhere in sight.

When director Liz Miller begins filming her documentary, Highland Park is on the verge of bankruptcy with a population of 16,000. The local government can’t maintain the city’s infrastructure and the tax base has declined to the point where levying enough money to continue city services seems impossible. The governor appoints Emergency Financial Manager Ramona Pearson Henderson to fix the city’s financial woes. With her team of well-compensated consultants, Henderson proceeds to cut city services, including closing libraries and laying off all but the most essential city employees.

Yet Highland Park is still broke. Henderson then decides to capitalize on the city’s one asset: the water treatment plant. Built in 1917 by the Ford Motor Company, the water plant provides clean water to the city’s residents at affordable rates. But the city needs money, and fast. So water rates are increased and expensive penalties are affixed to delinquent bills. The absurdity of fixing a rundown city by bankrupting its already downtrodden residents and jeopardizing access to an essential resource is prevalent throughout the film.

Residents begin receiving bills of up to $10,000 – an unexpected financial burden for anyone, but an impossible situation for people living on fixed incomes. If residents wouldn’t or couldn’t pay their water bills, water was shut off, and homes were even foreclosed as overdue bills were attached to property taxes. Caught in the middle is water department technician Tom White who – when he isn’t playing an active volunteer role in the community during his non-working hours – is responsible for reading meters, shutting off water, and dealing with disgruntled customers.

mosby_valmarian.jpg
Vallory Johnson (left) and Marian Kramer helped mobilize their struggling community to fight for fair and affordable water access. Photograph courtesy of the filmmakers.
Residents don’t take the increased water rates lying down. The water fight becomes an ethical issue that questions a citizen’s right, at what cost, to a necessary resource; you can’t live without water. A group of grassroots activists begins protesting, lobbying, and speaking out during city council meetings. The Water Front closely follows longtime Highland Park local and feisty advocate Vallory Johnson as she fights to stop the city from increasing rates and privatizing the water treatment plant. Along with the Chair of the Michigan Welfare Rights Organization, Maureen Taylor, and civil rights activist Marian Kramer, Johnson forms Highland Park Human Rights Coalition, eventually running Henderson and her team out of town.

Miller was able to gain incredible access to everyone involved in Highland Park’s epic water fight while letting the story unfold without prejudice. Her direction is not unbalanced, but it’s clear her sympathy lies with the underdogs – especially during interviews with insolvent and angry locals who are living with no water. She captures the callous financial team discussing how they are going to force desperate residents to pay their water bills, while taking home six-figure salaries. It doesn’t help that the team of consultants are paid over a million dollars during their four years on the job, which seems particularly exorbitant considering Highland Park was bankrupt when they arrived and they only furthered the city’s problems by driving residents out.

Highland Park’s water issues may seem like an isolated situation in an unknown city. But water is, unfortunately, changing from a basic human right to a highly prized and profitable commodity. As evidenced by the misguided decisions documented in the film, communities cannot always rely on their governments to maintain the local infrastructure. The power of citizens to contribute real solutions and transform their cities cannot be overemphasized.

The Water Front is an incredibly inspiring look at the universality of grassroots activism started by individuals who take matters into their own hands to effect real change. And that’s something that flows abundantly even during the direst of droughts.



About the Author
Jessica Mosby is a writer and critic living in Oakland, California. In the rare moments when she's not traveling across the United States for work, Jessica enjoys listening to public radio, buying organic food at local farmers markets, trolling junk stores, and collecting owl-themed tchotchke.

Comments (1)

The situation in this film seems to be typical of much of what is wrong with the US. A town bankrupt due to the outsourcing of jobs to squeeze more money from labor for the corporations, paying huge salaries to a few people who work to exploit water! This is insane, but goes on at all levels.

It is good that filmmakers are showing these kinds of issues and this one seems skilled in being able to gain people's confidence in order to show the situation. Thanks again to Jessica and the editors for letting us know about this film.

Ad Space Holder

Leave a comment

RECENT ARTICLES

Arts & Culture
Economy
Education
Politics
Science
Special Election Coverage
Technology
The WIP Editorial
The World