Heidi Zirtzlaff's Profile

  • Monterey
  • USA
  • Heidi Zirtzlaff studies international policy and conflict resolution at the Monterey Institute of International Studies, California, USA. She has studied abroad in Moscow, Tbilisi, Reykjavik, Haiti, Sierra Leone, Strasbourg, Amsterdam and Geneva.

Author's Entries

An Opportunity for Real Change: Building Peace in Sierra Leone

This was my first trip to Africa. I was traveling with a group researching the challenges Sierra Leone faces in building peace since the end of its 11-year war that lasted from 1991 to 2002. I had realistic expectations for the two-week visit, and I also had high hopes for falling in love with a new place. What I was not prepared for turned out to be their expectations for my visit. It turned out those expectations were quite high.

In hindsight I am not surprised that the people in Sierra Leone expected to receive money and other aid from a white person visiting their country from the West. After all, most of the people on our flight were going to Sierra Leone to build health clinics or for other aid-related work. I was another Westerner visiting Sierra Leone, but I had a very different mission there - to understand how my research in Sierra Leone fits into the larger picture of international aid and peacebuilding.


Children greeted us everywhere we went. Photograph by Heidi Zirtzlaff.

The first day of our visit, our bus driver’s assistant asked me to buy him some ice cream. Instinctively I said “no” and then felt a twinge of guilt. Over the course of our two weeks, I had more experiences that left me feeling like a dollar sign. The research group visited several amputee camps hoping to collect valuable information on the efforts of peacebuilding from the people whose lives had been so profoundly changed because of the war. But before they shared their stories with us, they always asked us for money. When we visited a village where we happened to be the first ever group of white visitors, the elders asked us what our plan was for them. In each case I was surprised by how forward the people were in asking for money or donations.

In the village I was relieved to learn that the villagers had a plan for themselves. They envision building a new community center with a tin roof to replace the current grass roof, which does not last through the rainy season. The villagers also plan improvements to their mosque. I was impressed with the work that the villagers had already done to clear a “road” through the bush so that visitors like us might come. The village was the exception, though. Most of the people we met seemed used to receiving money and donations from foreigners. It felt like they had come to expect help from the outside at the expense of their own sense of responsibility and empowerment.

I am still struggling to reconcile the role of the international community with the need for true grassroots, ground up, local visioning and action. I was surprised that the expectations for a group like ours were so high, and I was disappointed that some locals are not already doing more on their own. At the same time, I witnessed that the reality in Sierra Leone is one of desperate need. How much can locals be expected to envision a peaceful and prosperous future when they cannot feed their families today? Sierra Leone’s unemployment is higher than 50%. Many children are not able to attend school. Many young adults are struggling to make their way because they came of age during the war, and had no opportunity to do more than barely survive.

There is no question that the international community has some responsibility to help the people of Sierra Leone who may not be able to help themselves. I am concerned that the current efforts are not enough. Sierra Leone is in much the same situation now as it was before the war broke out. The efforts at peacebuilding to date, while noble, have not been enough by themselves. Unfortunately, Western aid has had the negative effect of creating unsustainable expectations that have led to a perpetuation of the status quo in Sierra Leone. Well-intentioned foreign aid has led people to wait for more and more aid to come.

The reality is that aid is not enough. Real and lasting change needs to come from within the people of Sierra Leone themselves. I know the desire for change is there; I saw it in their eyes and heard it in their voices. I know the international community is ready and willing to help. If the desire for a better future could be strategically coordinated with available resources, Sierra Leone would have a bright future indeed. Conflict brings the opportunity for change, unfortunately sometimes in the most violent way. Sierra Leone has an opportunity for change now. This is the opportunity that must be taken advantage of before it slips away. It would heartbreaking for Sierra Leone to have experienced all of the conflict and not to benefit from the change it so desperately wants and needs.

Heidi Zirtzlaff was in Sierra Leone for a two-week course led by Dr. Pushpa Iyer of the Monterey Institute of International Studies. Heidi's blog is part of a series of reflections by Dr. Iyer and her students on the challenges to building peace in this war-ravaged country. -Ed.

Heidi Zirtzlaff studies international policy and conflict resolution at the Monterey Institute of International Studies, California, USA. She earned her bachelor’s degree from Wellesley College, Massachusetts, USA. Heidi has studied abroad in Moscow, Tbilisi, Reykjavik, Haiti, Sierra Leone, Strasbourg, Amsterdam and Geneva. Through her travels, Heidi has come to believe that we all have more in common than we have in conflict. It is this belief that sustains Heidi’s hope for peace and understanding, even in today’s world.

Author's Comments

What continues to amaze me in spite of life's challenges is the ways individual women and men stand up for each other and make such a difference in each other's lives. I am really impressed with Zuhra's story. Thank you for sharing this with us, Gulayim!

Manar,
Thank you for sharing your personal perspective on what is happening in Egypt. After reading your article, I feel more connected to what is happening. At the moment I am watching Tahrir Square on television and waiting along with the Egyptians there to hear Mubarak's speech.... I am hopeful for the future of your country and your people!

The responsibility of the government is to protect the people. Smoking is banned because it is harmful for everyone, not just those holding a cigarette. But seeing my neighbor wearing a headscarf will never give me cancer. In fact, it makes me smile because I am always glad to see a woman confident enough to make a choice even when she knows it will be challenging.

As for boxes, people simply don't belong in them.

Eloisa, Thank you for sharing this perspective! I am disappointed to see Mr. Berlusconi in the headlines yet again, but I am so glad to hear that not all Italian women are just going along with his view of the world! Brava!

Pictures posted! Thanks, Brent!

Liz,

Thank you for this perspective!

Having just finished a master's degree in December, I know that here in the U.S. the cost of higher education is staggering. Really, it's scary, especially given the state of the economy.

Personally, I chose to pursue a master's degree because it was required for the jobs I wanted. My bachelor's degree was not enough to pursue a career in my field, international relations. Now more doors are opened to me, but I am responsible for a significant amount of debt. It's like having a mortgage, but without the place to live!

Heidi

It sounds like you're in a great location! I would certainly love to come stay in your hostel! I'll put it on my travel list.... I've been learning Spanish and am practicing by watching Harry Potter movies en espanol.

I am looking forward to hearing the results of the referendum! And I am hoping that violence is minimal. Fingers crossed!!

Kate, that has happened to me! I was walking home from school and a sports car pulled up beside me and rolled the window down. The man in the car asked me for directions, which I gave him. But then when I wouldn't give him my phone number he drove off in the opposite direction from how I'd told him to find the highway. Also, when I used to work as a receptionist people would be incredibly aggressive on the phone. I was called everything from the b-word to the c-word, and fat and ugly - on the phone! I don't understand how this kind of behavior has become commonplace. I'm pretty comfortable standing up for myself, but it is still disturbing.

Elisa, I am often most inspired by the work of grassroots community organizations, as you mention. Their ability to do so much with so little is truly amazing. For example, The WIP's most recent radio broadcast (click here for the podcast: http://thewip.net/talk/2010/08/a_nutritious_meal_and_an_educa.html ) interviewed two women who have made a very important impact in the lives of thousands of children in Malawi. With the Kasimu Education Fund ( http://www.kefmalawi.com ), donations go a long way: $300 provides one child with a year of education and meals. It's a profound reminder that even the most modest efforts of dedicated individuals can create enormous, positive change.