Secure the Water against the Starving - US Troops in Haiti
When you store your brains in your weaponry, then every situation is a security threat. US military in Haiti, hyper-vigilant about securing emergency relief, obviously missed the central purpose - get the supplies out to save lives.
When the Wall Street Journal presents Cubans as heroes and US soldiers as paranoid idiots, you know the screw-up must be off the scale.
"Benoit Leduc, operations manager for Doctors Without Borders in Haiti, on Monday said "hundreds of lives" were lost because five of its planes carrying surgical teams and equipment weren't allowed to land and were diverted to Santo Domingo."Several countries and other aid groups also have complained that the U.S. military has refused to let some of their supply planes land at Haiti's crippled airport.
""It's a question of physics," says Capt. John Kirby, a U.S. military spokesman in Haiti. "The airport is the only way in, it only has one runway, and there are literally hundreds of flights trying to make it in." "
- (Charles Forelle, Jose de Cordoba, and Joe Lauria, Wall Street Journal, January 17th, 2010)
Here's a suggestion. Give planes carrying doctors, and medical supplies, landing priority over those packed with soldiers. Like the two massive C17 military transport aircraft currently blocking the airport runway.
The U.S. military is reluctant to move shipments out of the airport without a security escort, sometimes causing added delays. "Twenty containers go out, but you have to have about 100 heavily armed soldiers," says Gilberto Castro, emergency response director of transport company Deutsche Post DHL, which is handling hundreds of tons of aid.
Right. Because food packages and bottles of water and bandages and painkillers need to be protected from starving, wounded people.
Yet a team of Cuban doctors were seen Monday treating hundreds of patients without a gun or soldier in sight. The deputy chief of mission at the American Embassy in Haiti, David Lindwall, said the U.S. had done a lot, but that some teams and supplies "aren't getting out as broadly as we'd like because of security" concerns.
Hmm. Did he happen to notice that relief teams from Cuba, Iceland, China, half-a-dozen other nations, are out there saving lives? Without security? Could that be because they see Haitians as fellow human beings, not rabid jackals they need to protect themselves from?
The Guardian's Ed Pilkington reports from Port-au-Prince:
Day seven of the catastrophe, yet wherever we go we are still surrounded by crowds of people living on the streets pleading with us for water. A few miles away at the airport huge quantities of supplies are stacked high in the sun. Under a deal finalised between the heads of relevant parties on Sunday night, US troops will be responsible for securing the incoming supplies at the airport, and then moving them to four central distribution hubs. One of those hubs is at the national football stadium in downtown Port-au-Prince and another at a golf course near the US embassy.
Ah yes - the Superdome Solution. It worked so well for Hurricane Katrina. Listen up, all you wounded, traumatized Haitians! Yes you, camped in the ruins of your home surrounded by your last remaining possessions. Yes you, keening in the rubble for your dead loved ones. Yes you, still frantically digging for survivors. A message from the US government: Just Let Go and head for a Hub. The US Marines are here to give you a Fresh Start!
Like Katrina survivors, when you finally return to your home or neighborhood, you'll likely find that bulldozers have completed the job begun by the earthquake. That foundations are already being laid for high-rises and luxury hotels, office blocks and swimming pools, for the influx of crisis entrepreneurs, aka Relief Workers. They'll be around for a decade or two.
And if you happen to be too injured to move, have infants or immobile elders you can't carry, if you just can't bring yourself to leave the bodies - bad luck. We've all got to make difficult decisions in disasters. Were you really expecting the relief to come to you? We've only got 10,000 troops here, lady! You want us to whip out maps and highlighters, mark off neighborhoods and just send our guys out with supplies? Whaddaya think we are - Cubans? It's dangerous out there. We may have assault rifles, but we've heard about your Voodoo.
Paranoia. Incompetence. Preemptive criminalization of disaster victims. Militarism-gone-mad. Secure the water against the starving. Force survivors to trek to the food and medical aid. But at all costs, keep the soldiers safe.
Shailja Patel is an award-winning Kenyan writer, theatre artist, and political activist. www.shailja.com

Thank you for opening up the excruciating stories of the sexual violence against women and girls.
They tend to get subsumed into the larger category of Post-Election Violence, and it is vital that they are heard, absorbed, and addressed, in all their horror, if we are to have anything resembling genuine justice in Kenya.
Posted by Shailja | January 21, 2009 10:18 AM